The Hotel Guru
Independent hotel reviews and recommendations
Line
What We Offer Why Trust Us Guru Blog Advice & Booking Sitemap
Home
The Hotel Guru

Edinburgh Hotels


Not just Scotland's capital city and an important centre of the late 18th-century Enlightenment, Edinburgh is now one of the most popular tourist destinations in Europe (in Britain, second only to London), its rich history in evidence everywhere you look from the famous Castle, towering above streets of genteel, granite grey houses, to the startling new and wildly over-budget Scottish Parliament building. Attractions range from the Festival, held over three weeks every August when the population swells to double, to the Military Tattoo and Hogmanay street party, to say nothing of its excellent museums and galleries or stylish shops and restaurants. As you'd expect, there's a wide choice of accommodation, whether you plump for a luxury hotel in the shadow of the Castle or one of the bed-and-breakfasts that have sprung up around the city and are proving popular, good-value alternatives. The hotels are listed by price category, and their order bears no reflection on our preference. Reviews by Fiona Duncan
Find Another Top Ten Hotel
Search
 
 
The Witchery by the Castle
Luxury:  Flamboyant, captivating restaurant with rooms
Location: Castlehill, The Royal Mile: at the Castle gates
Hotel Hotel
Mysterious, captivating, exotic: James Thomson’s Gothic conversion of the 16th-century General Assembly of the Church of Scotland is named after the witches that were burned nearby. It is flamboyantly decorated with gilded ceilings, panelling and swathes of jewel-coloured velvet. Huge sumptuous suites in vibrant colours are theatrical and supremely romantic, with four-posters and oil paintings. Extras include complementary champagne.
The Howard Hotel
Luxury:  Spoiling Georgian townhouse with butler service
Location: Great King Street: in New Town, just east of Dundas Street
Hotel Hotel
Stay here for a taste of gracious living Regency-style. In three refined Georgian town houses on a quiet cobbled street, afternoon tea is served in the elegant drawing room, breakfast in a room decorated with charming, original Italianate murals, and a grandly sweeping staircase leads to the luxurious bedrooms. And leave the chores to your personal butler.
The Scotsman Hotel
Luxury:  Stunning transformation of former newspaper building in the heart of the city
Location: at the top of North Bridge, close to Princes Street
Hotel Hotel
The city’s most unusual hotel is a stunning transformation of the Scotsman newspaper's former offices. The conversion is a dramatic blend of the old and new, where Victorian oak panelling sits happily beside ultra-modern glass and steel. Bedrooms – you can even sleep in the editor’s office – are super-comfortable, and there’s a fabulous health club, spa and private cinema. Friendly staff.
Prestonfield Hotel
Luxury:  Opulent hotel in parkland just five minutes from the Royal Mile
Location: Royal Holyrood Park, 5 minutes from the Royal Mile
Hotel Hotel
Surrounded by gardens and parkland but minutes from the city centre, this enveloping hotel has just 22 bedrooms, yet guests are treated to an Aladdin's cave of opulence, drama and romance, from complementary champagne and chocolate on arrival to the run of three fabulously decorated drawing rooms, a whisky bar and a fine restaurant, Rhubarb. Attentive service; gorgeous bedrooms; sheer glorious indulgence.
Ingrams
Mid Price:  Charming, antiques-filled B&B
Location: Northumberland Street, near junction with Dundas Street; a 5-minute walk from Princes Street
Hotel Hotel
It will come as little surprise to David and Theresa Ingram’s guests that David used to be an antiques dealer: the four-storey listed Georgian town house (with glorious flying stone staircase and oval cupola) that they have turned into a charming B&B is full of handsome period furniture, pictures and objets. The three bedrooms (one double and two twins) are comfortable, attractively decorated and well-equipped.
Tigerlily
Mid Price:  Youthful, lively restaurant with rooms
Location: George Street; one block from Princes Street
Hotel Hotel
A lively bar and restaurant combined with a sleek, contemporary hotel, which subtly balances comfort and style. Rooms have thoughtful touches, including loaded iPods, DVD players, Egyptian cotton sheets, massive showers or baths, even umbrellas. The bar buzzes (particularly on Saturday nights), and you must book the restaurant well ahead. Staff are enthusiastic and efficient.
Channings Hotel
Mid Price:  Cosy, welcoming and elegant townhouse hotel  including breakfast
Location: South Learmonth Gardens, just outside New Town, 10 minutes walk from west end
Hotel Hotel
Widely known as Edinburgh's cosiest and most welcoming – yet very elegant – hotel, Channings was created from five Edwardian townhouses in a quiet residential area just outside New Town. With the feel of a homely Scottish country house, including antiques and open fires, the hotel also offers stylish bedrooms, some with fine rooftop views, plus a highly acclaimed restaurant and a laid back wine bar.
Seven Danube Street
Mid Price:  Comfortable, welcoming bed and breakfast in a fine house
Location: in Stockbridge; a ten-minute walk to Princes Street
Hotel Hotel
A real home from home, this fine house was designed by James Milne in the early 1800s and is now owned and run as a B&B by Fiona and Colin Mitchell-Rose. It has three lovely guest rooms and a genuinely welcoming atmosphere. Always mindful of their guests' comfort, Fiona and Colin provide a host of little extras. The garden and separate entrance are bonuses and, if you’d rather self-cater, they have an apartment nearby.
Windmill House
Inexpensive:  Quiet bed and breakfast close to city centre yet in a lovely rural setting
Location: Coltbridge Gardens: 1 mile west of Princes Street
Hotel Hotel
If you prefer the idea of a B&B in a more rural setting but still within walking distance of the city centre, Michael and Vivien Scott’s elegant Georgian-style house will fit the bill. It has a splendid position above the Water of Leith, in 2-acre grounds, containing a waterfall, weir and (17th-century) windmill from which it takes its name. There are log fires, three large stylish bedrooms and a friendly atmosphere.
 
 
Line
Space
Space
Line
Space
Contact Us | Terms & Conditions Space © Copyright 2006. The Hotel Guru. All rights reserved.