Top Inns in Cape May (2026)

As one of the oldest seaside resorts in the USA, Cape May isn’t short on history and character. For this reason, our Gurus recommend booking a stay in one of the town’s original properties, making an inn an ideal choice for a real sense of place. The range of inn-style accommodations in Cape May is not huge, but we've managed to track down a revamped beach motel and a grand Victorian mansion. Enjoy period furnishings, contemporary design touches, and inviting communal spaces, all within close proximity to the pristine beaches and local attractions.

For a romantic getaway

• The Harrison is a charming B&B in a former Victorian home. Its contemporary take on opulent 19th-century decor combines Renaissance-style furnishings, period armoires, wall coverings, and sleek marble bathrooms. A quaint porch is perfect for afternoon tea. For couples, the Summer Cottage provides a private hideaway complete with a hot tub and a fireplace.

For a boutique

• The Star is a classic beach motel revamped with modern boutique interiors. Rooms, suites and multi-bedroom bungalows are situated just steps from the sand, and with use of the facilities of the nearby sister hotel, offer great value. The decor blends a fresh white palette with jewel-tone furnishings and colour pops. A fab beach base.

Still not sure? 

• Browse through our full list of accommodations in New Jersey
• Consider our favourite properties on the Jersey Shore
• Alternatively, you could contact one of our friendly Gurus for personalised advice.