The best hotels in Ithaca, NY

Photo of Ithaca, NY
Credit: By LBM1948 - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0
Photo of Ithaca, NY
Credit: Image by Guillermo Galmes from
Photo of Ithaca, NY
Credit: Image by Qianyi Luo from Pixab
All hotels in Ithaca, NY Apartments & villas in Ithaca, NY Find more hotels in Ithaca, NY

About Ithaca, NY

What are the best hotels in Ithaca, NY?

Ithaca sits at the southern tip of Cayuga Lake in New York’s Finger Lakes region, surrounded by forested gorges, spectacular waterfalls, vineyards and rolling countryside. Home to Cornell University, the city has a lively feel, with independent shops, farm-to-table restaurants, cosy cafes and laid-back bars around its pedestrianised Commons. There’s plenty to explore, from lakeside adventures and wine tasting to scenic hiking trails in nearby state parks. For the best place to stay, Argos Inn stands out for its beautiful Victorian mansion, individually styled rooms and excellent cocktail bar, making it a characterful base for exploring both the city and the wider Finger Lakes.

Scroll down the page for our full selection of recommended hotels in Ithaca, NY or, for a look at different areas, read our guide to the best places to stay in New York State.

Some of our New York State Collections:

13 Top Resorts in New York State

The Best Places to Stay in Ithaca

For Couples

  • Argos Inn is a charming historic inn set within an imposing Victorain mansion in Ithaca. Kick back in one of 13 stylish rooms, stroll around the city and enjoy top-class craft cocktails at the lively onsite bar. For a grown-up city stay.
  • The Inn at Gothic Eves boasts eight elegant suites with sumptuous interiors, perfect for an indulgent couples' escape. Feast on organic breakfasts and unwind with onsite spa treatments after big days of exploring the Finger Lakes area. Very chic.

For Families

  • The Grayhaven Motel is a laid-back collection of 16 historic rooms, suites and cottages. Expect carefully restored interiors featuring mid-century modern pieces and lovely views over the property's 11 acres of leafy grounds. Self-catering options and flexible cottage sizes are ideal for families or groups.

For an Apartment or Holiday Cottage

  • If you'd prefer a self-catering option, we suggest that you visit our online partner Booking.com.

Travel Information

  • Fly to Ithaca Tompkins International Airport, three miles from Ithaca. Travel by bus or taxi to your destination from there.
  • Alternatively, contact our online partner Rentalcars if you would like to hire a car. There's so much to see and do in the Finger Lakes region.
  • Time your trip for the summer months (June to September) to enjoy warmer temperatures, ranging from 20 - 25°C. Autumn is slightly cooler, but the blankets of red, orange and yellow leaves are seriously striking. This is a hugely popular time to visit, so book your stay well in advance to avoid missing out!

Still not sure?

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

The Hotel Guru is a curated hotel recommendation platform that delivers expert-selected luxury and boutique properties straight to your inbox. No spam. Only sweet updates about the latest hotel openings and the best places to stay.

The best hotels in Ithaca, NY

Argos Inn

Argos Inn

Ithaca, NY (New York State)

Set in an imposing old colonial mansion, this hotel combines modern style with old-world charm. Chic rooms feature polished wooden floors, warm hues and antiques. A grown up property offering impeccable design and an alluring craft cocktail bar. The perfect base to explore Ithaca from.

  • Local exploring - A spoiling base to explore the state's natural bounties including vineyards, waterfalls and gorges
  • Eco break - The environmentally-friendly Argos Inn has geothermal heating and is LEED certified
  • Great walks - The city is surrounded by magnificent waterfalls and famous gorges for stunning days out hiking
  • Lakeside - Cayuga Lake is approx 3km away
from $168 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees
Check availability on Expedia
The Grayhaven Motel

The Grayhaven Motel

Ithaca, NY (New York State)

Charming laid-back motel in rural Finger Lakes. Set on 11 acres of woodland, home to local wildlife, the property is made up of spacious rooms, suites and cottages with airy mid-century design and decor. Some have kitchenettes and dining options are in driving distance. Ideal for families or groups.

  • Total relaxation - Make the most of the property's acres with walking trails, outdoor firepits, picnic areas, lawn games, hammocks and birdwatching
  • Back to Nature - Finger Lakes area offers countless state parks, waterfalls, lakes and forests. Enjoy fishing, hunting, skiing and wild swimming
  • Artworks - There is an artists-in-residency program for writers, illustrators, media artists and calligraphers
  • Business meetings - Book the property exclusively for a fun laid-back offside retreat for up to 50 guests
from $185 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees
Check availability on Expedia
The Inn at Gothic Eves

The Inn at Gothic Eves

Ithaca, NY (New York State)

A charming inn located in the heart of Fingers Lakes. Suites are elegant and spacious with custom tiled bathrooms, heated bathroom floors, fireplaces, jetted tubs and showers with body sprays. Hammocks are strung up in the garden and delicious, organic breakfasts are served. A relaxing stay.

  • Local exploring - The Finger Lakes area is well known for its deep lakes, bountiful harvests, wine, ciders, beers, music scene and the arts
  • Romantic Break - Book a room with a four-poster and indulge in the couples' massage that comes when booking the 'couples package'
  • No restaurant - Breakfast is provided
  • Sights nearby - Visit a variety of attractions including Watkins Glen, Cornell University, and Ithaca College
from $358 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees
Check availability on Expedia